The SNP Administration's Budget proposals were voted through at the Budget meeting on Thursday
21 February. This means that cuts to primary school teachers, to support workers in schools and school budgets were voted through.
I am disappointed that our sensible proposals to protect education spending, to stop the on-going attack on the terms and conditions of council workers and to spend more on health and social care were rejected. You can read more about our proposals here.
During the debate I spoke in favour of our proposals.
There were many disagreements during the council meeting but there is one thing that the council is still united on. It remains the policy of Dundee City Council that Dundee needs a better settlement from the Scottish Government. The council's lobbying has so far fallen on deaf ears. The budget may well have been passed but we need to keep up the pressure to make sure that, at the very least, next year Dundee gets a fair deal.
Our proposals would have utilised more of the council's reserves. This is because we are clear that this is the rainy day. There is no point in building up reserves at the same time as cutting jobs and services.
I remain concerned about the on-going attacks on the terms and conditions of the council's workforce. The Labour Group proposed to delete the proposals to attack the terms and conditions of the workforce. All the trade unions, who made excellent contributions through their deputations, said that they would be happy to work with the council, to look at any proposals put forward, but said that they would not agree to plans which hurt workers terms and conditions. We hear lots of pious talk about the workforce being the council's biggest asset but talk is cheap, it is actions which count.
Labour's proposals would have protected a whole range of voluntary organisations such as Barnardos, Action for Children, One Parent Families and Victim Support among many, many others. The fact that under 43 different headings in the voluntary sector there was to be a 5% cut shows that there had been very little thought about how this might impact on service delivery. Instead there was an arbitrary cut of 5% proposed. We tried to protect this investment, but the SNP voted through this cut.
We also wanted to spend more on Health and Social Care than the SNP. We proposed an amount targeted at reducing hospital re-admissions and issues around trips and falls. This would utilise social care workers more effectively and prevent any proposals for split shifts amongst these essential workers.
The SNP put forward proposals to cut funding to Dundee's cultural bodies other than the V & A. We proposed to continue to support Dundee Heritage Trust, Dundee Science Centre, the DCA and Dundee Rep and Scottish Dance Theatre as well as the V & A. We also proposed extra funding for Dundee Rep and Scottish Dance Theatre to allow them to do even more community work. Given that Dundee prides itself in its cultural activities it is bizarre that these cuts were pushed through. Remember that this council wanted to be European City of Culture in 2023.
Most importantly our proposals tried to delete all the savings in the education budget. It is crucial that we give every young person in Dundee the best start in life. Officers said that these cuts would impact on the education in our schools. Our plans would have stopped the 3% cut to school devolved budgets, it would have stopped the rise in prices for school breakfast clubs and preserved the Kick It Kick Off programme. Our plans would have recognised and valued the work of support staff in our schools. Instead we will have the situation where Pupil Equity Funding is used inappropriately to cover for cuts in mainstream budgets. That was called cheating when I was at school.
Our proposals were a budget for the many not the few, a budget which would have protected the future of our city by saving jobs and services.